
There’s a task you’ve been meaning to do for days. Maybe it’s an email, a work project or a form you need to fill out. You open it, stare at it, and close it again. Then you clean the kitchen, scroll your phone, or reorganize a drawer. By evening, you’re frustrated with yourself. “Why can’t I just do it? What’s wrong with me?”
If that sounds like you, I want you to know something right away: you’re not lazy. What looks like procrastination is very often perfectionism in disguise.
Wait, perfectionists procrastinate?
It surprises a lot of people. We tend to picture perfectionists as the ones with colour-coded calendars who finish everything early. But many of the perfectionists we see in therapy are stuck, not because they don’t care, but because they care so much that starting feels risky.
Research backs this up. In a large review of studies with about 10,000 people, psychologists Fuschia Sirois, Danielle Molnar and Jameson Hirsch found that procrastination goes hand in hand with a particular kind of perfectionism, called perfectionistic concerns. That’s the side of perfectionism made up of harsh self-criticism, worry about how others see you, and a constant sense of falling short of who you “should” be.
Here’s how that plays out. If anything less than perfect feels like proof that you’re not good enough, then not starting becomes a way to protect yourself. As long as the work is unfinished, it can’t be judged. Delay buys a little relief now, but it usually costs more stress, more guilt and more self-blame later.
The “never good enough” feeling
Alongside procrastination, many people describe a quieter ache: the feeling of never being good enough. You finish the project and immediately notice what’s missing. Someone compliments you and you brush it off. You hit a goal and the bar quietly moves higher.
Psychotherapist Patricia DeYoung helps explain why. In her book Understanding and Treating Chronic Shame, she describes shame as the felt sense of the self falling apart in relation to a “dysregulating other,” someone who couldn’t stay attuned to us when we needed them. She traces chronic shame back to early relationships where feelings were either shut down or out of control.
DeYoung also points out something important: chronic shame feels like a private, personal failing caused by our own negative thinking. But it isn’t. It’s relational. It grew in relationship, which means the message “something is wrong with me” was learned, not discovered.
Seen through this lens, perfectionism makes a lot of sense. It’s a shield. If I can just be flawless, maybe no one will see the part of me I’m afraid is unworthy. Procrastination is often what happens when the shield feels too heavy to lift. And “not good enough” is shame’s voice, quietly narrating the whole thing.
Why “just try harder” doesn’t work
If you’ve struggled with this, you’ve probably been told to make a to-do list, set a timer, or lower your standards. But if shame is driving the bus, productivity hacks rarely reach the root. You can’t schedule your way out of feeling unworthy.
How Tobi Baker works with perfectionism
This is where therapy with Tobi Baker, MSW, RSW, can make a real difference. Tobi is a long-time therapist at The Healing Collective, and Tobi’s approach is attachment-focused. That means, instead of only tackling the procrastination itself, Tobi gently explores where the need to be perfect came from: what you learned, early on, about being loved, accepted and safe.
This fits DeYoung’s work beautifully. Because shame forms in relationship, it heals in relationship too. In sessions with Tobi, you get to bring the parts of you that feel messy, behind or “not enough,” and be met with warmth instead of judgment. Over time, that experience helps your nervous system learn something new: you don’t have to earn your worth. And when that starts to shift, it often gets a lot easier to begin.
You don’t have to wait
If any of this sounds familiar, there’s nothing wrong with you. The Healing Collective offers no-waitlist therapy across Ontario, both virtually and in person on the Danforth in Toronto. Reach out at healingcollective.ca to book with Tobi.
References
- DeYoung, P. A. (2015). Understanding and treating chronic shame: A relational/neurobiological approach. Routledge. Publisher page
- Sirois, F. M., Molnar, D. S., & Hirsch, J. K. (2017). A meta-analytic and conceptual update on the associations between procrastination and multidimensional perfectionism. European Journal of Personality, 31(2), 137–159. Abstract